Thursday, April 26, 2012

Week 8 Supplemental Post - Selznick Comparison





Selznick, B. (1991). Houdini. New York: Atheneum Books for Young Readers.
Selznick, B. (2007). The invention of Hugo Cabret. New York: Scholastic.           
Selznick, B. (2011). Wonderstruck. New York: Scholastic.


This blog will compare three of Brian Selznick’s picture books: Houdini, The invention of Hugo Cabret, and Wonderstruck.  These works use the artistic media of charcoal pencil (Lynch-Brown, Tomlinson, Short, 2011, p. 87) and are picture books for older readers ages 8-12 (Lynch-Brown, et al., p. 110).  As well, all three display the ability and efficacy of a combination of text and illustration to convey narrative. But the way in which they do so is proportional to their intrinsic sophistication regarding same. On a continuum of least to most sophisticated Houdini is an example of the former: Though in terms of space Houdini is divided equally between text and pictures, the story is told almost completely in the text. The pictures don’t replace the text or function in its stead but act as foil.  

Selznick accomplishes this using artistic media of charcoal pencil to create a subdued atmosphere. Plot, character and mood in the text proper are enhanced but not overpowered by the illustrations.  Though Selznick uses the cartoon technique of outlining objects, the figures are soft and all faces lightly indistinct. Further Selznick uses a crosshatch texture to demodulate the impact of the figures. This approach is ideal because it perfectly captures the aspirations and dreams of a little boy who delights in magic. Happily though for a time disillusioned about Houdini, through his own son the narrator is able to reconnect to the magic Houdini inspired and by book end has rediscovered the magic in himself

While Hugo Cabret builds on this same use of artistic style, media and visual elements to deliver plot character and theme the book shifts away from an equal partnership of text and illustration. Instead the illustrations themselves function as a vehicle of narration. As a result illustration and text are no longer evenly balanced but articulated successive ‘chunks’ of illustration and  text.

Thus the reader is no longer provided visuals to illustrate the text but given narration in a completely visual manner. Within a short period of time the reader easily shifts between word and picture narrations while at the same time never losing track of the story and consequently its apprehension is taken to a much deeper level. Selznick lets us both see and read the story and soon the reader is unconcerned which – text or illustration – is foregrounded and completely absorbed in the story.

                                       

 Hugo Cabret also ‘illustrates’ the title character’s inventiveness through sub-narratives of his life in the train station and his relationships with the toy seller and the toy seller’s god-daughter  and his wife.  And as it unfolds Selznick incorporates the history of Hugo’s father the inventor and the toy seller who is actually Georges Méliès, creator of film. But at no time does the story stop revolving around Hugo of which the partnership of text and illustration never loses sight.

Finally Wonderstruck is the ultimate transmogrification on the continuum of the relationship of illustration and text that has been encountered so far  in Houdini and The Invention of Hugo Cabret. But it goes one step further: Wonderstruck inculcates what appear to be completely separate narratives through most of the book by telling Rose Kinkaid’s story in illustrations without text and Ben’s story – at least in the first two thirds or Parts – in just text.
  
 
Consequently up until Part 3, we ponder what possible relationship these seemingly disjointed pictures and text say about their respective protagonists relationship. In Part 3 the illustrations and text begin to intertwine and interoperate connecting Ben and Rose and making everything clear. It is an amazing book.

Personally I was not thrilled with one aspect of The Invention of Hugo Cabret: The title character was at times a petty thief and it seems Selznick hadn’t a problem with that. This ‘smudged’ the book’s ending in a celebration of the invention of film and Hugo’s budding career as a magician. It seems Selznick lost the opportunity not to preach to adolescents but let them know that even pilfering for survival entails the felonious and should be at least questioned. 


I had no reservations about Wonderstruck. It was just so incredibly creative about all the things I love: Museums, science, artistic endeavor and creativity all grounded in the possibility that all human relationships hold potential for wholeness.  Both Ben and Rose were healed and what started as fragments of disjointed chronology blossomed into the importance and security of family and friends.

                                          

Question for instructors: How could the The Invention of Hugo Cabret and Wonderstruck be used in read alouds?.

Question for students:  How do The Invention of Hugo Cabret and Wonderstruck teach us about the importance about character and our own character’s impact on the choices we make.  

Activity: Use “So What” Thinking Strategy” to build a class activity. For instance in Wonderstruck try to determine what possible connection their might be between Ben’s text-based narrative and Rose’s illustration-based narrative and then predict how the book might end. Work in pairs or small groups to contextualize the history of film and dilemma of inventors in World History. How does impact which inventors finally get a chance and obtain success.

References

Lynch-Brown, C. L., Tomlinson, C.M., & Short, K.G. (2011). Essentials of children’s literature,

            7th ed. Boston: Pearson.





Week 8 Post - Non-fiction booktalk blog


Freedman, R. (1993). Eleanor Roosevelt: A life if discovery. New York: Clarion Books.

Note: Parenthetical in-text citations below are for the presenter only. They will not be included in actual talk.

The subject of today’s booktalk is Russell Freedman’s biography about Eleanor Roosevelt titled simply Eleanor Roosevelt. Characteristically modest and self-effacing, Eleanor Roosevelt said about her decade as First Lady: “I never wanted to be a president’s wife and I don’t want it now…..Now I shall have to work out my own salvation” (Freedman, 1993, p. 97).         Fortunately for all of us she worked it out. For the history buffs in our literature class who love background information about the periods we are studying for historical context that recounting will be a treat:  Born in 1884, Eleanor Roosevelt lived through and participated in all the great events of the first 60 years of the 20th Century.  

The daughter of New York blue-bloods or upper class parents, Eleanor was painfully shy as a child, easily frightened and very self-conscious of her plain appearance.  At 8 Eleanor’s mother died and at 10 her father.  Of those events, she recollected, “The bottom dropped out of my own particular world and I faced myself, my surroundings, my world, honestly for the first time. I really grew up that year.” (Freedman, 1997, p. 63)

She was raised by her maternal grandmother who fulfilling her promise to her daughter sent granddaughter Eleanor at 15 to a finishing school in England. There Eleanor blossomed acquiring the confidence and thoughtful decisiveness that were to serve her beautifully throughout her life. Returning from England at 18 for her coming out or debut into New York Society, Eleanor was reintroduced to her cousin Franklin Delano Roosevelt who not only became her husband but was elected to four terms as U.S. President.  

Eleanor Roosevelt was remarkable because she rose to every challenge. What makes the book Eleanor Roosevelt remarkable is that it is unflinchingly honest about her: When her husband began an affair with her secretary, she demanded he stop it and simply refused to ever again engage in conjugal relations with him. When her husband became Governor of New York State she supported him and when he contracted polio and was crippled she was there for him. Her response to his illness was to serve him and ultimately both him and us when he is elected U.S. President. Eleanor Roosevelt put it this way: “If anyone were to ask me what I want out of life I would say – the opportunity for doing something useful, for in no other way, I am convinced, can true happiness be attained. “  (Freedman, 1997, p. 77)

Eleanor Roosevelt was a completely modern woman before it was acceptable to be one. She became involved in politics, wrote for newspapers and lectured, travelled for her husband in all his terms as president. When Franklin Delano Roosevelt finally passed away at the beginning of his fourth term she continued to be active in the United Nations especially in its campaigns for international peace many of which she helped start. Eleanor Roosevelt served in some official capacity under Truman, Eisenhower and finally John F. Kennedy. At the end of her life she said in perfect summation: “Life has got to be lived – that is all there is to it.” (Freedman, 1997, p. 147)

Monday, April 23, 2012

Week 7 Post


Lyon, G. E. (1988). Borrowed children. New York: Watts.

My blog this week will explore how Borrowed Children by George Ella Lyon exemplifies historical young adult fiction by meeting the evaluative criteria posited on page 168 of the text: First, It has an engaging story with  rounded and complex characters that age wise at least go from little Helen (then baby Willie) through Anna, Amanda (Mandy) the protagonist and Ben up to David the oldest. Second, the book – centered around Mandy  age 12 hence a young adult read – presents verifiable historical facts in an objective fashion about the Depression in rural and urban Tennessee while honoring the dialects of both its country and city folks. And third, in creating the jazz element in Memphis at that time presents persons of color (though not foregrounded) as talented and interesting (Lynch-Brown & Tomlinson, Short, 2011, p. 168). 
 
The narrator and protagonist Mandy Perritt is a perceptive young person who is given a great deal of responsibility when her mother becomes ill after the birth of little brother William. While at first reluctantly rising then resignedly to the occasion, Mandy both observes and makes very insightful comments about everything and everyone around her.

The first instance is the charming bedtime story about the foundling with which all three girls identify: Each asks herself “Was I that baby, is that how I came to be a Perritt.” (Marking time bookmark Comprehension Strategy, pp. 15-19).  Here Mandy is older sister cum mother. Lyon continues to establish her specialness by talking about her love of learning. When required to temporarily quit school to help her mother, Amanda’s teacher Mr. Aden, sends her a book titled The Romantic Poets. Up early one morning falsely alarmed by her concern for Willie she enters her mother’s room and finds both infant and mother soundly and blissfully asleep. The quote

          Now while the birds sing a joyous song,
              And while the young lambs bound,
                       As to tabor’s sound,
      To me alone there came a thought of grief…  (Marking time…p. 45-6)

from William Wordsworths’  “Ode, Intimations of Immortality from Recollections of Early Childhood" (Wordsworth, 1875) perfectly captures young Amanda’s burgeoning inner life. Always the thinker and budding scholar, Mandy  carefully casts her eye upon the world around her and its troubles. 

This book also contributes historical rectification of the fact that though things were hard, Jim Perritt is a successful sawyer. This is taken further when Amanda is sent to visit her Grandmother Omie and Grandfather Opie. The grandparents are prosperous as best one can be at that. But this is not a book about failure. Rather it is about the awakening of a young woman to her possibilities and dreams. Mandy's mother chose to move to mountains with the man she loved and was willing to set aside her love of music for her family. The beauty of the book lies in the parents understanding that Mandy might have other dreams which enables them to send her to Memphis to begin her quest. As a consequence Mandy realizes the mountains are her home and willingly goes back knowing that she in future will have the right - a terrific message for young adult readers - to leave. 

Like Amanda I was precocious and ravenous about books. I like her was also a “questioner.” I really like the fact that though adults around are taken aback by her persistent and insightful questions they as best they can answer them. I also like the way in which Lyon reveals that this family has chosen live in the country not because the father Jim Perritt hates the town but because that is where feels happiest and where he feels he belongs.  

Questions: Why do people assume all mountain and country people are hillbillies? What positive and negative role models does Lyon provide? And how does Lyon show a real human being actually being a bit or a lot of both?

References

Lynch-Brown, C. L., Tomlinson, C.M., & Short, K.G. (2011). Essentials of children’s literature,

            7th ed. Boston: Pearson.

Wordsworth, W. (1875). Bartelby.com/Ode on intimations of immortality from recollections of

early childhood. Retrieved April 23, 2012 from http://www.bartleby.com/106/287.html.
                                                         

Monday, April 16, 2012

Week 6 Post

Angelou, M. (1970). I know why the caged bird sings. New York: Random House.

Maya Angelou’s autobiography – a subset of biography – I Know Why a Caged Bird Sings fits squarely in the Realistic Fiction genre because it includes a factual recounting of the lives of real people through their “experiences, influences, accomplishments and legacies (Lynch-Brown, Tomlinson, Short, 2011, p. 171).” Angelou’s autobiography also impinges on fictionalized autobiography because she creates dramatic episodes populated with imagined conversation from things that actually happened to her (Lynch-Brown, Tomlinson, Short, 2011, p. 173, par).

                                   VHS wrapper 1979 made-for-TV movie version  (Wikipedia, 2011).

Up through Chapter 24, Angelou chronologically recounts her life and those in it:  Her arrival in Stamps, Arkansas from St. Louis, Missouri at age three with older brother Bailey Johnson,  Jr. after their mother and father’s divorce to live with their paternal grandmother Annie Henderson who she calls Momma; how she adjusts to small time life; going back to St. Louis briefly to live with mother and when that fails – she is raped by one of her mother Vivian’s friends – returning to Stamps; and finishing school grade school.

Interestingly at this point the story ever so briefly becomes fictional: Maya has to go to a dentist but there isn’t one who is black so Momma takes her to Dr. Lincoln the town’s white dentist. When he refuses to treat Maya because she is black Angelou uses this as an opportunity for Momma to give a powerful peroration on the economic power of black people. Momma had loaned this man money to save his dental practice and scolds him into treating Maja, saying things a black woman might have thought but wouldn’t have dared – at least at that time – say. It is an impressive and beautifully written speech.




 At 13 Maya moves to Los Angeles then Oakland, California and finally San Francisco with her mother who in the latter city marries Daddy Cidell a good male role model.  Maya spends a summer in Mexico with her indifferent father and his hostile girlfriend Dolores. There she undergoes further teenage vicissitudes including living in a junkyard with homeless teenagers. When Maya returns to San Francisco, at only 15 she becomes – despite racist hiring policies – a streetcar conductor. The book’s chronology ends with Maya confidently raising the son she has had out of wedlock.
  
I taught this book in my IB Literature class in Beijing in spring 2010 so it was interesting to revisit it and reconsider what still worked and what still didn’t: Angelou is a master of physical detail. Her depiction of Momma’s store at the beginning of the book when she first came back is a miracle of description because it lets us really feel how this little girl is finally grounded in a palpably secure environment. This came back in the rereading with the same power it had the first time. But as I did then, I find the plot uneven: The interlude in St. Louis where she is raped is a bit contrived and her Mexico hiatus with her father and his Mexican girlfriend unconvincing. And I didn’t and still don’t feel the book ends effectively. It seems to come out of nowhere, seems tacked on to the rest of the book. 

When Angelou describes places though – like the store and the forest clearing where she and Louise her grade school friend bond – the book is wonderful. But setting aside personal biases, in my experience Caged Bird really connects with young adult readers, especially youths of color. For instance, I had a young Tanzanian in my class who had never been to America and had no idea of how racist America could be even be even today. But it wasn’t the racism that Angelou captured that touched him: It was how real she made her characters and how she ennobled them. I suspect he also really liked Bailey, Jr. because he was like Bailey very talented and very unfocused. 

Finally the book is an excellent read for young adults because Angelou is very honest about sexual issues and shows how a young black female teenager can overcome them. She also successfully navigates through relationships with various males including fathers, father figures good and bad and boyfriends and in the main negotiates good outcomes for herself. Maya is clearly not bitter and by book end has decided that man or no man she will survive.

Question: What relationship does work ethic have to do with racism?  Does racism affect men and women differently?


                                                                  References

Lynch-Brown, C, Tomlinson, C.M. & Short, K. G. (2011). Essentials of children’s 
            literature. Boston: Pearson.
Wikipedia.. (2011). I know why the caged bird sings. Retrieved from http://en.
            wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Know_Why_the_Caged_Bird_Sings_%28film%29)

Monday, April 9, 2012

Week 5 Post

Walker, F. X. (2000). Affrilachia. Lexington, KY: Old Cove Press.

This blog entry will explore Affrilachia by Frank X. Walker. It will consider the power of poetry to capture various kinds relationships in contemporary Black American experience – here in Kentucky – in an unrestrained fashion. This resultant panoply lies at the heart of Walker’s poetry. 

                                            
            The poems in Affrilachia are lyrics that express Walker the poet’s emotional response to relationships between people, experiences and things. For instance “Death by Basketball” presents the dream of a small boy to be a basketball star who plays ‘air basketball’ when he gets off the school bus and under the street lights in the evening during the latter which he is killed by a stray bullet in a drug pushers’ shootout. The poem gets its cadence from random alternation of 3,4, 5 and 6 syllable lines that when read give the sensation of a person dribbling a basketball.
“Fireproof” recounts the faithfulness of a black congregation as it rebuilds their torched church. The using the same 3,4,5 and 6 syllabic line configuration of “Death by Basketball.” But "Fireproof" has a smoothness and a forward driving pulse that replicates the persistence of the congregation’s faith. In the last stanza, Walker uses 3,3,2,4,2 syllable lines

                                                        church people
        are fireproof
                                                        and Faith
        won’t just go up
        in smoke

to iterate a turning of the product of fire – smoke – and paradoxically figurate faith’s indestructibility.
            These poems show Walker’s mastery of simple diction to convey how people feel and believe and the consequences. They are not abstract. Consistent with this, the third poem chosen for this blog, “Breakfast in Hazard,” is an homage to Carl Sandburg’s poem “Fog.” But instead of a cat metaphor Walker plays with a food image of gravy over biscuits and spider spun webs to convey the pervasiveness and blanketing quality of this weather phenomenon. Comprised of an eleven and a ten stanza – two in all – , the cadence is light and airy and Walker leverages his Kentucky images to have some fun as well as localize Frost’s poem. 

                                                                
I enjoyed Walker's poems because they tap into the potentials of contemporary black experience. I have at various points in my life been involved with Blacks here in the U.S. Most recently, I have been assisting in the building of a mission in Zambia. In both cases, I find it wonderful that Walker has so accurately captured what to me is the beauty and complexity of the Black persona and consciousness.

Big Question: How and why does the title Affralachia connect the poetry therein to the region where it was spawned as well as to other parts of the U.S. and the world?

Tuesday, April 3, 2012

Week 4 Post 2

Chase, R. (1976). Grandfather tales. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.


  This second posting for Week 4 is a Traditional/Multicultural book because it is set in the  Appalachians and contains folk and tall tales as well as songs.It is comprised of narratives that have their origins in the U.S. as well as Europe. In all cases, the stories are accessible to young children as well as adolescents. The book is built around an Old Christmas gathering where a researcher is recording tales told by adults to a group of young people. This is important because we are made aware that this retelling - like all narratives from the oral tradition - will be different from all previous and all subsequent retellings.
    Also, Chase has beautifully preserved the Appalachian dialect. For instance "get rid of" becomes "shet", "boiling" becomes "b'lin'" and "stropped" for "strapped." When read in dialect young listeners get the added enjoyment of as well as important exposure to hearing the colloquial speech patterns of individuals from other parts of the U.S.



                            Mutsmag 

This story is important because it shows how resourceful the female protagonist Mutsmag was overcoming the objections of her sisters Poll and Betts when they go to seek their fortunes. Not only does she save them from a wicked witch but ultimately kills the witch and her henchman the evil giant. Mutsmag also  retrieves the King's prize horse which the latter has stolen. Faced with unfairness and adversity, Mutsmags prevails over both and is handsomely rewarded. Interestingly reference to the King indicates this story probably originated in the Appalachians before he American Revolution.
 
                                                                                                 Whitebear Whittington

In this story, another female protagonist is required to go with a "beastly" white bear because her father had stolen some roses from him. The white bear is also a handsome young man under a spell: During the day he is a bear and during the night a man. She marries him and they have three children. When she becomes homesick, he says that she can take their three children and go home for a visit with the understanding that she must not tell anyone his name is Whitebear Whittington. But her father pesters her and she finally gives in which causes her husband to be banished from her. The young woman goes to look for him and after much difficulty finds him and rescues him. In this story, the faithful and indefatigable love of a wife saves her family. According to Chase's notes this story is an amalgam of several American folk tales. Though Chase doesn't say so, I think it probably has its ultimate source in the European classic "Beauty and the Beast." 

The Old Sow and Three Shoats

This story is "The Three Little Pigs" told "American style."  The interest of this story is that though the fox eats the first two little pigs because they don't listen to their mother, the third outsmarts and eats him!


                                                  Like Meat Loves Salt

The fourth and last story is "Like Meat Loves Salt." This is a retelling of King Lear, where the honest third daughter saves her father. At first, when asked how much she loves him she responds, "Like Meat Loves Salt." Offended he banishes her to a tower from which the Duke of England rescues her. But she still saves him. It is especially interesting because its English origin has been refracted to show the American themes - the truths of a work - of love for honesty and for rewarding merit. 

Regarding this week's Notes, these tales will also help young people in Appalachia take pride in their unique cultural heritage that goes back colonial time and draws a plethora of European antecedents which it then turns into a kind of literature that is uniquely Kentuckian. Young people from here will realize that these "hillbilly's"created something wonderful. Those from elsewhere will come to respect the vibrant oral tradition this represents. For all these reasons as well as  their supreme accessibility Chase's Grandfather Tales is an excellent choice for class read aloud's.   

Big Questions: How would you retell any one of the stories as if it where happening today? 
Activity: Write a dramatization of one of the stories and perform it for classmates. 



Week 4 Post 1


Myers, W.D. (1999). Monster. New York: HarperCollins.

Monster by Walter Dean Myers is one of the Traditional/Multicultural selections for this week because it explores the ethnic diversity of New York City and helps non-urban young adults not only understand the problems and dangers of living a big city but the meaning of a person's character. This blog will explore Myers use of limited omniscient point of view to get at the big question at the heart of the book:  How can we know someone is telling the truth?   
    In limited omniscient point of view we know everything about one character, here Steve Harmon, an aspiring film maker. Myers effects this by constructing Monster as the shooting script of the film Steve plans to make to recount his experience as one of the multiple suspects and then defendants in a felony murder case that goes to trial. Myers intertwines entries from the journal Steve keeps of his experience with courtroom dialogue - judge, defense attorneys, prosecutor, defendants and spectators - , the prison where Steve is held and script setting instructions like camera angle and type of shot (close up, long, medium, etc.) letting readers construct the novel's plot and characters. 
    In a nutshell four individuals are accused of planning a drugstore robbery during which the drugstore owner is murdered. Steve Harmon is the alleged lookout for the robbery. Myers never has Steve tell us directly that he was an accomplice. We only have hints he might have been: A dialogue between him and Osvaldo another alleged perpetrator; his not wanting to write in his journal what he saw happen in the drugstore; and Detective Karyl's saying that the other perpetrators said after the robbery it was Steve he turned back and shot the store owner. We also have Steve's suspicion that his defense attorney Miss O'Brien thinks he is guilty as well as her coaching him on how to take the stand and answer in a way that shows he is innocent. 


This book works because Myer makes us the reader a kind of jury: We are never told what actually happened. We have to piece it together like the jury in the book. Throughout the novel we the readers ask ourselves, "Was Steve Harmon an accomplice?" Like the picture above where the person looking into he mirror is not the person reflected, is Steve Harmon lying about his innocence? When he is acquitted and Miss O'Brien refuses to embrace him as well as Steve's December 5 journal ending the book do we have the truth: Steve was an accomplice!.
    The book is challenging and wonderful because the reader is asked to look at whether s/he knows when someone else is telling the truth and being able to back up her/his conclusion. It also challenges young readers to define and evaluate what a person's true character is and of what importance it is.These are both things with which young adults are faced: Like Steve Harmon they will have to live with the consequences of lying and/or telling the truth.
    Memorable Quote from last page:  "I want to look at myself a thousand times for one true image." When I read this, Irealize I have looked at myself ten thousands of times and that one image would never be enough. I am a diverse, multi-faceted, complex, contradictory yet centered human being. A better quote would be "The best simplicity comes from never ameliorating but embracing and celebrating the complexity from which it is born."